Letting Them Rest in Peace

westport battle
Battle of Westport

The last mortal casualty of the Civil War was laid to rest over 150 years ago.  Somewhere around 750,000 people died in that war. Most of the soldiers died from disease — for every three killed in combat there was another five who died from disease.  Many more were maimed for life.

There is a great deal of agitation and consternation over the future of the Confederate flag and what it actually stands for. To claim that the flag stands to memorialize and honor Confederate soldiers who died in a misguided and vain attempt to preserve slavery (yes, that’s what it was about in the south) is to, conversely, dishonor and minimize the efforts and sacrifice of Union soldiers who also died in the conflict in the struggle to preserve the Union and abolish slavery. Many soldiers’ lives were cut short even if they survived the war. My great-grandfather died from complications from a Civil War injury long after the war ended. Another relative suffered thirty years of pain with a war injury until he finally had his leg amputated in the  1890s.

The Confederate flag doesn’t stand for or serve the purpose that it was originally intended. It is now mostly a tool to symbolize obstructionism and white privilege. No matter what you think of it or it’s history, today it is the bigot’s flag. It was once vilified as “the traitor’s rag” and has evolved into the “bigot’s rag”.

Slavery and the Civil War were horrendous things in our history. I was born and raised in Missouri, a one-time slave state. The Civil War there was particularly brutal on all sides.  Slavery in Missouri was not as widely practiced as in the deep south but had a particular ugly aspect — one not much talked about.  Slave plantations in parts of Missouri were essentially stock farms where slaves were bred and then shipped south.  Slaves could not be imported into the United States after 1807 so there was a business side  to the “peculiar institution” — making baby slaves that could eventually be sold south to large agricultural plantations. I’m sure this went on all over the south but it is seldom talked about. Where do you think all those slaves came from?

The killing of the nine church members in Charleston is not directly related to the Confederate flag.  The murders are related to the mindset and bigotry that the flag represents.  The flag bolsters and fosters the hate and aggression that permeates the minds of too many people…not just in the south. That’s how the murders are connected.  You can see Confederate flag “do-rags” on bikers in California or any state. The flag decorates pick-up trucks in Michigan or Idaho or anywhere in the country. Six-year-olds wrapped in Chinese-made Confederate flag beach towels in Texas or Cape Cod don’t (yet) know what that symbol is about but others with them or seeing them do and it won’t be long before they figure it out.

It is time to grow up and put all of that behind us. This is not “political correctness” as right-wingers like to complain about. They don’t fly Nazi flags in military cemeteries in Germany. Put the flag in a museum — there is no place for the Confederate flag in public or government institutions or business…as in state flags or license plates.  It’s time we laid it all to rest.


4 thoughts on “Letting Them Rest in Peace

  1. When black people are killed every day in big cities no one cares, but when one mentally ill kid on drugs has a delusional hatred the story blows up. Suddenly every white person is responsible. If we really thought all lives mattered we’d be discussing what goes on at planned parenthood and in the inner cities. The big story here is how the congregation of Christians behaved like incredible Christians. So tired of the constant need to turn the races against each other.


    1. There seems to be organized forces at work driving us apart. Sometimes it’s easier to see this in other countries than in our own…Rwanda, Ukraine and Yugoslavia might be some examples. There are others and it almost seems like a deliberate plan of action. Here in the US there have been great strides forward in racial relations the last 60 years but it doesn’t take much to destroy what progress was made. In spite of the progress, there are still obstructionists who would preach hate and want to go back to the way things were.

      You are right in your observation that the congregation actually lived and professed their faith and beliefs after the tragedy. I suspect that most people couldn’t do that. We seemed to be programed to judge and to find fault. This year there will be a projected 33,000 gunshot deaths in the US…all of them unnecessary. There will be more gun deaths than automobile accident deaths this year. We hear a lot of pro-life rhetoric but to be truly pro-life a person must also be anti-gun. There are mighty forces at work to divide those issues.


      1. Have you ever read More Guns, Less Crime? Its a very interesting study of statistics. One thing the author points out is that in states where concealed carry is legal there is less violent crime.

        There’s more going on than just guns, I think. In some countries people hack each other to death. Its a problem of the human heart. I once slept soundly while two men fought with machete’s in the street over drugs. One of them died.


  2. Thirty years in the criminal justice profession tells me otherwise. You are right that it is a problem of the human heart but also one of sociopathic manipulation, power/weakness, and lack of education-values-opportunity.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s